Climate Change Skeptics

The Visual Math Institute
Global Climate Change Modeling and Simulation

The case against the climate catastrophe prediction
by Ralph Abraham

As part of our review of the Daisy World models of James Lovelock and co-workers, we collect here some remarks on the limitations of the predictive value of mathematical models and computer simulation.

Many thanks to Marvin Greenberg for these links.

Bjorn Lomborg, Wall Street Journal, November 7, 2006. Critique of UN Climate Panel report, Nicholas Stern's review, and the UK government Mario Lewis, CEI, March 16, 2007 Critique of Al Gore's movie Freeman Dyson, TCS Daily, April 10, 2007. Critique of climate models The case against Al Gore, The New Party, 2007. Nine inaccuracies Freeman Dyson, The Edge, August 9, 2007 More climate heresies London Telegraph, September 9, 2007 John Coleman calls global warming a scam John Christy, IPCC, Wall Street Journal, November 1, 2007 A skeptic within the IPCC US Senate Report,Debunks Consensus, December 20, 2007. 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Critique of UN Climate Panel report, Nicholas Stern's review, and the UK government
Mario Lewis, CEI, March 16, 2007 Critique of Al Gore's movie Freeman Dyson, TCS Daily, April 10, 2007. Critique of climate models The case against Al Gore, The New Party, 2007. Nine inaccuracies Freeman Dyson, The Edge, August 9, 2007 More climate heresies London Telegraph, September 9, 2007 John Coleman calls global warming a scam John Christy, IPCC, Wall Street Journal, November 1, 2007 A skeptic within the IPCC US Senate Report,Debunks Consensus, December 20, 2007. 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Critique of Al Gore's movie
Freeman Dyson, TCS Daily, April 10, 2007. Critique of climate models The case against Al Gore, The New Party, 2007. Nine inaccuracies Freeman Dyson, The Edge, August 9, 2007 More climate heresies London Telegraph, September 9, 2007 John Coleman calls global warming a scam John Christy, IPCC, Wall Street Journal, November 1, 2007 A skeptic within the IPCC US Senate Report,Debunks Consensus, December 20, 2007. 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Critique of climate models
The case against Al Gore, The New Party, 2007. Nine inaccuracies Freeman Dyson, The Edge, August 9, 2007 More climate heresies London Telegraph, September 9, 2007 John Coleman calls global warming a scam John Christy, IPCC, Wall Street Journal, November 1, 2007 A skeptic within the IPCC US Senate Report,Debunks Consensus, December 20, 2007. 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Nine inaccuracies
Freeman Dyson, The Edge, August 9, 2007 More climate heresies London Telegraph, September 9, 2007 John Coleman calls global warming a scam John Christy, IPCC, Wall Street Journal, November 1, 2007 A skeptic within the IPCC US Senate Report,Debunks Consensus, December 20, 2007. 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: More climate heresies
London Telegraph, September 9, 2007 John Coleman calls global warming a scam John Christy, IPCC, Wall Street Journal, November 1, 2007 A skeptic within the IPCC US Senate Report,Debunks Consensus, December 20, 2007. 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: John Coleman calls global warming a scam
John Christy, IPCC, Wall Street Journal, November 1, 2007 A skeptic within the IPCC US Senate Report,Debunks Consensus, December 20, 2007. 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: A skeptic within the IPCC
US Senate Report,Debunks Consensus, December 20, 2007. 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: 400 scientists disagree with the IPCC
Alexander Cockburn, The Nation, June 27, 2007. Oops, this page has vanished David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Oops, this page has vanished
David Whitehouse, UK Met Office, January 3, 2008 Critique of the UK Met Office report G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Critique of the UK Met Office report
G. V. Chilingar, L. F. Khilyuk, O. G. Sorokhtin Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription) Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Cooling of Atmosphere Due to CO2 Emission; Energy Sources/A, January 2008 (requires subscription)
Phi Brennan, NewsMax, February 19, 2008 Suddenly the ice has returned Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Suddenly the ice has returned
Daily Tech, March 6, 2008 Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error) Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Zagoni says the greenhouse equations are totally wrong (Ferenc Miskolczi has corrected the error)
Christopher Booker, London Telegraph, March 9, 2008 Climate is now cooling Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Climate is now cooling
Charles Clover, London Telegraph, April 30, 2008 Warming will stop until 2015 Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Warming will stop until 2015
Steven Goddard Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998) Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Warmer or Cooler? Report on a new model from the Leibniz Institute of Marine Science; NASA (warmer) vs three others (cooler since 1998)
Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, May 15, 2008 Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Report on the 2008 conference of climate skeptics
Michael Asher Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008 IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Science Blog, Daily Tech, July 16, 2008; IPCC taken to task by Lord Monkton
Anastasios Tsonis, Univ, of Wisconsin, Milwaukee, March 15, 2009 Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001 Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Chaos theory supports a cooling regime since 2001
Marc Sheppard, American Thinker, March 15, 2009 Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change." Concensus: there is NO CRISIS Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Oregon Petition against the IPCC, signed by 31,00 scientists; "...over 800 scientists, economists, and policy makers arrived in New York City last Sunday to attend the Heartland Institute’s 2nd Annual International Conference on Climate Change."; Concensus: there is NO CRISIS
Paul Sheehan, The Sydney Morning Herald, April 13 2009 Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Book review of the about-to-appear Heaven and Earth by Ian Plimer; NB: This book, now available, obsoletes most of the references above
James Dellingpole, The Spectator, July 8, 2009 Interview with Professor Plimer: Interview with Professor Plimer

And many thanks to Bruce Stewart for these links.

CO2, methane and temperature from the EPICA ice core, realclimate.org
Princeton GFDL study of deep ocean ventilation, PDF (720 KB)
N. Caillon, J. P. Severinghaus, et al.
Timing of Atmospheric CO2 and Antarctic Temperature Changes Across Termination III.
Science 14 March 2003:Vol. 299. no. 5613, pp. 1728 - 1731. Abstract.

Others:

The Petition Project (from Ralph, December 13, 2007)
NiceNeCouncil.com (from Nathan Eppler, 1/-2/08) 13, 2007)
Climate Lies, by the Viscount Monckton of Brenchley (from SPPI blog, 12/27/09, thanks to Nick Herbert)

Revised 01 August 2009 by Ralph

The Visual Math Institute Global Climate Change Modeling and Simulation

The case against the climate catastrophe prediction by Ralph Abraham

The Visual Math Institute
Global Climate Change Modeling and Simulation

The case against the climate catastrophe prediction
by Ralph Abraham